AKA | |
First Published | 1879 |
Writer/composer | WH Phillips | Roud | RN1532 |
Music Hall Performers | GH MacDermott, Harry Yorke |
Folk performances | Collected from the singing of: Oliver, Alfred; England : Hampshire 1907 Hambridge, Charles; England : Berkshire; c1915 Ling, Alderman; England : Suffolk 1953 Poacher, Cyril England : Suffolk; c1964 Lee, Jack `Hoopiron’; Australia : New South Wales ; no date Modern performances Jim Eldon Gemma Khawaja |
From Broadside in Frank Kidson collection VWML Now once there was a maid kept an old magpie, And a parson who prayed lived very close by; When this maid met the parson they both stopped to talk And often on the quiet go for a cosy walk; But her lover was a sailor, who sailed across the main, And he promised she would be his wife when he returned again, Still she let the parson see her home from church, And kiss her never thinking of the magpie on the perch. The maid and the magpie would talk all the day. The maid would believe all the magpie would say, She said I love the parson, but don't you tell the tar." When the old magpie only said, "Quar, quar!" Now while this sailor was away so the story goes, This maid flirts with the parson but of course nobody knows, Until she tells the magpie when talking one day, She'd rather have the parson now the sailor is away, But she said don't tell this secret or I'll give you the birch, Every night at nine I meet the parson by the church, The magpie only quar-quar'd as he had done before, But he meant to tell a sailor boy when he returned on shore While stationed at Gibraltar the sailor so it seems, When sleeping in his cosy bunk he had some funny dreams; He dreamt the girl he left behind on dear old England's shore, Would whilst he was away flirt with half a dozen more So he made his passage homeward, as quickly as could be, Landed safely at her house but no maiden could he see; He then talked to the magpie who was dancing on the perch, And the magpie told him all about the parson at the church. Now when the sailor met the maiden he passed her with disdain, So she sued for breach of promise, tried five hundred to obtain; But he brought the magpie into court, which told the truthful tale, So to get what she required the maiden did fail. She then went for the parson but in vain for him did search, For he knew which way the wind blew so he hooked it from the church; The lawyers couldn't find him, so the case went on the shelf, And this tricky little maiden had to dwell by herself. The maid and the magpie ne'er talk all this day, For the jolly little sailor took the knowing bird away; And now, with all his shipmates, this rare good-hearted tar, While the magpie tells the truthful tale, he sings - "Quar! Quar!"
A song written for the Halls which seems to have passed into the oral tradition, collected from several traditional singers in southern England, and once collected in Australia.
The maid and the magpie was written by WH Phillips and was first sung by Harry Yorke in late 1878:
It became better known as part of GH MacDermott‘s repertoire, and was the subject of a dispute in the letters page of The Era – looking back it can feel like a bit of a storm in a teacup. But this was a time when ownership of a popular song could be very financially rewarding and disputes of this type were very common.
The publication of the song follows a fairly typical pattern for that period – printing sheet music was still relatively expensive and only tended to occur only when there was a serious prospect of it appealing to a wider market. If a song entered the repertoire of one of the major stars (like GH MacDermott) it was almost bound to get published – lesser-known writers and performers like Phillips and Yorke had to prove the value of their song…
Harry Yorke (1852-1923) was a popular comic who began performing in the mid-1870s in the Halls of North West England. He was described as “the coming Leybourne” (see George Leybourne) although according to the Oldham Express he “met with a warmer welcome and more enthusiastic applause than the great lion comique ever received in Oldham”. In his later career, between the late 1880s and 1910, he managed theatres in Blackburn and Preston.
WH Phillips (b/d unknown) seems to have been a writer and performer particularly active in the late 1870s and 1880s. He is credited with writing this song The cows won’t milk and the bulls won’t roar and around 10 others between 1879 and 1882.
Gemma Khawaja sings it:
Sources:
- Entries in the Roud Indexes at the Vaughn Williams Memorial Library: https://archives.vwml.org/search/all:single[folksong-broadside-books]/0_50/all/score_desc/extended-roudNo_tr%3A1532
- Kilgarrif Sing Us
- Lyrics: broadside in Vol 5 of Frank Kidson collection at VWML
- WorldCat entry for Sheet Music
- As collected by Alfred Williams Wiltshire Community History
Last Updated on May 4, 2022 by John Baxter | Published: March 27, 2021